Death arrives quickly and often in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, through which a sick inevitability permeates the air around and the heart within our protagonist. He’s Haymitch Abernathy, who was introduced to us in 2012’s The Hunger Games and its three sequels (all four adapted from three books by Suzanne Collins) as a cynical drunk with a lot of blunt pragmatism about the reality of the “games” of the title. There is only one reason why he would know enough reality to offer such advice, and in the process of showing us how he came to all those conclusions, this movie proves itself to be quite, quite bleak, even in the context of a series like this one.

One might recall how this works: Each district of Panem—a version of America far into some dystopian future—produces two tributes, a boy and a girl each, to fight to the death in an arena and for the entertainment (or punishment) of the rest of the country. This resulted from some past rebellion of an unclear origin, and in the series’ original chronology, it sparked a rebellion, which brought down the games with the help of a guerrilla revolutionary group and their appointed leader. That cycle of films (excepting the second one, perhaps, which actually felt urgent and dangerous) was a bit muddled in its application of this political allegory, especially in a bifurcated final installment that displaced one type of tyranny with another, significantly less developed one.

The two prequels—2023’s The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes and now this film—have somehow done a better job of tackling that allegory, despite the fact that their individual stories possessed only a sense of inevitability and a single trajectory, so as not to break the continuity of the overall saga. That’s why the bleakness and the predictability of this tale works in its favor: Haymitch (Joseph Zada, in a performance that moves far beyond being a pretty good impersonation of Woody Harrelson, who played this role previously) may well be the most tragic figure in all these stories. The filmmakers have done the character justice by leaning into the tragedy.

On the surface, it doesn’t seem like Haymitch—who hails from District 12, just as that eventual rebel leader will—has a story that’s all that different from anyone with his status or in his position. It’s his birthday as the movie begins, on the day of the Reaping that will determine the four tributes (because this is a Quarter Quell, which demands some kind of commemorative stakes-raising) to be sent to this year’s arena. He does not expect to be picked, and indeed, two others are, until a series of events are set into motion that result in his selection (the others are played by McKenna Grace, Ben Wang and Molly McCann).

Some of this film is an act of revisiting the past films (and, therefore, the future stories) with a few pieces of clever casting: Kieran Culkin as game host Caesar Flickerman, Elle Fanning as bubbly stylist Effie Trinket, and a trio of actors—Maya Hawke, Kelvin Harrison Jr. and Lili Taylor—as previous winners who offer their services to the newcomers. The most important characters to return are Coriolanus Snow (Ralph Fiennes), who oversees things with cool detachment and icy threats, and Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons), here just a cameraman playing both sides of the political arena. Offsetting all of this, and providing the film’s single most terrifying special effect, is Glenn Close as Drusilla Sickle, an escort whose cold eyes peer out from behind stretched and frozen cheekbones that have plastered her fake smile in place.

The games are the usual series of elaborate traps that are as deadly as the other tributes, and it’s Haymitch’s number-one job to survive them, even as he makes promises—ones he cannot keep, of course—to some of the others (one, played by Percy Daggs IV, is smart enough to begin developing an alliance right off the bat, masterfully throwing the Capitol for a loop by advertising it loudly). For Haymitch, it’s all a way to get back home to District 12, where a family and his girl (played by Whitney Peak) await. Everything else, including the possibility of a revolution from within more than just the arena, can wait, as far as he is concerned.

We know what must happen with and to this character, and we also know, in the back of our minds, just how bleak a lot of this must become to get to that point. Director Francis Lawrence (who has helmed every entry since the first sequel) and screenwriters Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie are smart not to look away as the carnage reaches a tipping point, but those unfamiliar with the trajectory of the novel might be unaware of what awaits Haymitch, not only around every corner in the arena, but by the end of this unflinching carousel of misery and woe. For a character who is happily sober to wind up that cynical drunk of many years later, only one sort of life could possibly be his future.

Subjectively speaking, much of The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is treading familiar territory (a trio of last-minute appearances from some familiar faces underscores that, to be sure), but that’s not the point of this particularly solid installment in the franchise. The point is more nuanced than that: For one character in particular, the inevitable was also inescapable, and it was only an entire generation later that anything, or anyone, could change it.

Rating: *** (out of ****)

One response to “Film Review: “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping””

  1. […] Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, The […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

I’m Joel

Welcome to Joel on Film!

I ran a website with this title for several years, ultimately shutting it down amid the recent pandemic. But I’m back at it now, and I hope you enjoy the weekly reviews!

Let’s connect

Recent posts