Film Review: “Madden”

Where does even hope to begin with Madden, an alleged biographical account of a couple decades in the life of its subject, the legendary head football coach—and, later, legendary sports broadcaster—John Madden? One supposes we could start with Nicolas Cage’s performance as the man, even if that seems like the easy route to take, but then again, there is almost nothing to say about it. The actor, who can be great or outrageous depending on the role, approaches this one as if he’ll let the body suit, the blond wig and the weirdly throaty voice do all the work for him, which might be an act of self-defense against a screenplay that has no idea what to say and a director who has no idea how to say whatever that is.

All of this, to be clear, is surprising to say, if only because the director is David O. Russell, who is—if nothing else—a notorious control freak on movie sets, and the screenplay, by Russell and Cambron Clark, has such an apparently easy job to do. The story of John Madden was always one of those that would inevitably come around on the assembly line of proposed screen biographies, and the director is even someone whom one could say making a pretty good version of that story, which involves rising status in a number of national-football avenues at the expense of his relationships and his health. Somehow, in some way, Russell has done such a disservice to that story that it feels like an intentional act of sabotage.

How else are we to take the multiple scenes in which the film’s version of John, having found his way into the press box at a football stadium, comes across as some kind of subterranean being who has just discovered the concepts of both televised entertainment and social interaction? Everyone watching eventually begins to realize the alleged genius of the man, and we’re sort of forced to accept that they realize this, because, after all, this is actually where Madden found his joy in his post-coaching career. Russell and Cage frame these scenes as a sort of absurdist farce at the expense of John, who stumbles and mumbles his way into changing the entire game of sports broadcasting.

This arrives after a whirlwind of an opening hour that details the first decade of this story, beginning in 1976 with the Oakland Raiders’ attempt to secure a championship with him as their leader and culminating with his decision to step away from that part of his life as his health begins to fail him. John is a bit of a farcical presence here, too, with a wife, Virginia (Kathryn Hahn), and kids he pays little attention to and an arguably much better relationship with his best friend Al Davis (Christian Bale), also the team’s owner. The narrative bounces around his attempts to revive team spirit while a bleeding ulcer forms in his gut.

After his retirement, the narrative also bounces around, as boredom sets in for the sports legend and other opportunities—the broadcasting gig, an eventual deal with a major video-game developer (John Mulaney appears as the president of that company, whose employees are dramatized as hopeless nerds in a business that sounds like Greek to John and Al)—raise their heads. It’s all without rhyme, reason, attitude, genuine reflection or anything else of merit or even of value, as the actors barrel, directionless, through the onslaught of jokes (without wit), events (without context) and ideas (without actualization), as well as the lack of a clear beginning to this story reflect by the fact that it just kind of comes to a resolution at a random point in his later years (a brief montage that thins John’s hair and turns it white, while a few other random events occur, doesn’t cut it).

It all comes across as a joke played mostly on us—an unfunny joke, with a sour build-up to the lack of a clear punch line. Russell has been a good filmmaker (whatever his other, more personal foibles) in the past, but Madden only displays a pedestrian sense of momentum, a flat visual language (even more disappointing, as the cinematographer is the usually great Robert Richardson), a considerable dearth of understanding its subject or wanting to contend with his legacy, a roiling contempt for any sincerity in approach, and an apparent disdain for its audience.

Rating: zero stars (out of ****)

One response to “Film Review: “Madden””

Leave a Reply

I’m Joel

Welcome to Joel on Film!

I ran a website with this title for several years, ultimately shutting it down amid the recent pandemic. But I’m back at it now, and I hope you enjoy the weekly reviews!

Let’s connect

Recent posts