Gentle Monster is an unapologetically tough film, in which an apparently happy family of three—a wife, her husband and their son—is torn apart by allegations that are genuinely shocking and occasionally breathtaking in their implications. It almost feels unfair to reveal what those allegations are, because they’re almost beside the point of writer/director Marie Kreutzer’s film. In fact, they’re a little bit too much beside the point here, which is to construct a reflexive study of a pair of characters going through similar things, too often at the expense of each other for the movie to make a clear point beyond the one right there on the surface.

The point, once we hear what Philip (Laurence Rupp) has done, is that Lucy (Léa Seydoux), his wife, recriminates herself constantly in the wake of an issued warrant and a disturbing reason for his arrest: Should she have seen, all this time, what he was doing for all those hours shut up in his room, claiming to work on a new television program when he was actually, as he puts it, “doing research” for a documentary feature? If she even suspected at all, shouldn’t she have intervened? How, for that matter, could she have intervened when his claim, offered upon his arrest instead of before it, might have warded her off the need to leave, right then, and take their son Johnny (Malo Blanchet) with her?

These are all loaded questions that are permanently stuck in her throat amid the shock and regret and disgust she feels when Elsa (Jella Haase), an officer with the local police department who carries out the warrant and arrest, rather bluntly states the reasons this small family has found itself in this predicament. Questions will be asked, accounts will be given—including by the boy, for reasons he probably cannot understand or grasp—and word will spread to those closest to them, because that’s what happens in tightly knit communities. Finally, she packs up and retreats to the city, where her mother (played by Catherine Deneuve) might not ask too many questions and where she and Johnny might find a little peace.

Seydoux’ performance here is a large part of the reason the film works as well as it does for the long stretches it does, indeed, work. The actress, studied in the art of understatement, allows the tears to well, the emotions to build, and the words to explode out of her, only when absolutely necessary, in the scenes that become sort of confessionals between Lucy and Philip. It’s great, affecting work from one of the cinema’s more recent massive talents, which makes the sort of indecisive and evasive drama around her all the more regrettable.

In a subplot that builds upon its own potential in similarly mixed and questionable ways, Elsa has her own set of problems at home, having to do with a father (played by Sylvester Groth) who requires at-home care and has been taking advantage of it in some pretty gross ways. Namely, he’s been sexually harassing—sometimes with physical contact—his live-in nurse, and the unfortunate thing about it all is that Elsa might not be in a position to send him anywhere else to live at this point in her life or career. Haase is solid in this likewise-tricky role, but the entire thread feels like an excessive complement to the main plot—a layer of melodrama too thick and too heavy to be served well by its being an addendum of sorts.

Amid all this, the film does position Lucy and Philip, as well as Elsa in her own way, as figures worthy of a certain fascination. The couple are both artists of a sort, as she performs covers of famous pop songs by transforming them into smaller, almost chamber pieces of a type and he films around their property, developing a director’s eye that looks a lot more like a voyeur exploring his fancies. Elsa is a cold traditionalist in her professional life, even as her personal ones crumbles to pieces, delivering news and otherwise engaging with Lucy and Philip without so much as a whisper of emotion.

Once the truth is revealed, it’s all about a cyclical process of learning new information, some of it either canceling out or informing earlier pieces of it, until the fullness of the picture comes into focus, even as closure remains frustratingly just out of reach. That, ultimately, is how the whole of Gentle Monster, which is forceful as a drama about shocking truths and consequences but rather unfocused as a character study, feels—just out of our reach.

Rating: **½ (out of ****)

One response to “Film Review: “Gentle Monster””

Leave a Reply

I’m Joel

Welcome to Joel on Film!

I ran a website with this title for several years, ultimately shutting it down amid the recent pandemic. But I’m back at it now, and I hope you enjoy the weekly reviews!

Let’s connect

Recent posts