
Being Heumann has the right idea, which is to tell the story of the fight for civil disability rights from the perspective of those who did the fighting, but co-writer/director Siân Heder also has the right idea, which is not to sugarcoat or cheat about the ways in which the story is also often frustrating, circular and—outside the context of underdog tales like it—dreadfully familiar. The subject here is Judith “Judy” Heumann, whose memoir is the basis of a screenplay co-written by Rebecca Taussig, and the plot is centered around a specific accomplishment, which was to make certain that a specific provision in a 1973 bill was being enforced and enacted. It’s a broadly inspirational story, of course, and with its success came a type of hard-won happiness.
The point of this dramatization, though, is to show all the ways in which the work itself did not contribute to a story we could call “happy.” Indeed, it’s quite alarming, when we arrive at the moment a certain signature is acquired, to register how random, how banal, and how anticlimactic it actually is—except, of course, for the fact that it happened, that these people succeeded in their work, and that, as a result of that provision, people with disabilities all across the United States could receive equal protection under the law and an equal education without discrimination. This is likely how more movements in the United States likely happened, with a victory that, in the moment, felt a bit random and a lot sudden.
As for the film’s version of Judy, she’s played by Ruth Madeley, an actress who—like her counterpart—has used a wheelchair since early childhood, and even more actors here similarly share either the conditions or the living arrangements of their own counterparts. This certainly extends the equitable circumstances of the manner in which Heder has cast and directed her film, although it also proves itself the right decision for other reasons, too. To put it plainly, beyond looking a bit like Judy, Madeley is quite, quite good here at realizing the prickly personality, the foul-mouthed vocabulary and the reckless confidence in the face of the scenario that leads to—as of the latest metrics—the longest sit-in for civil rights in American history.
Indeed, the entire crux of the story here is a form of inertia as action, when Judy and her fellow advocates find themselves up against a proverbial brick wall of protocol when trying to take their case to the government officials who could do something about their predicament. Even employing the initially reluctant help of television reporter Evan White (Dylan O’Brien), who begins at a place of dismissing the concerns of these people for want of easy soundbites and news clips, doesn’t entirely help when the government in question can simply restrict press access under the guise of trumped-up security claims. Yes, it’s a little disquieting to see scenes like a disastrous press conference, where Evan finds himself in the position of being able to ask questions of the people in charge and is then escorted out, in a present political landscape where that behavior is now the norm.
On the other side of this fight is Joseph Califano (Mark Ruffalo), the Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare under President Jimmy Carter, who refuses to sign regulations that would enforce and enact provisions under the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Califano is a stubborn and rather militant man, played by Ruffalo with a short fuse and a greater desire to stumble out the back window of his home than to talk to the activists or their leader, who needles the Secretary with phone calls practically by the half-hour. Califano’s claims of wanting to be fiscally responsible are obviously thin and not at all acceptable, although it’s generous of the movie to paint him, not as a one-note villain, but as a generic sort of politician whose support or opposition could be a coin flip, based entirely on his mood that week.
At first, it’s a battle of wits between Califano, who would rather answer a protest with a tyrant’s fist, and Judy, whose confidence in her fellow activists is unwavering—even when push comes to shove and the others are less certain. Heder is, once again, smart about depicting the sit-in, which occurs on the fly and pretty much immediately, as a nightmare of logistics (explained to Judy rather judiciously by Ed Roberts, another activist played by Michael Patrick Thornton) for a group of people whose basic needs sometimes exist outside the padlocked doors of the government building in which they have planted themselves. For just shy of a month, these people stayed where they were, provided food and assistance by outside help (including, for a fun bit of trivia, the Black Panther Party, on account of a member of theirs, played by Antwan Tolliver, being diagnosed with multiple sclerosis).
Again, this is not a happy story for a long time, because the measures implemented by Califano are often brutal and downright obstructionist, including eventually barring food and medication from entering the premises (this leads to a hunger strike that, naturally, is also a logistical nightmare and just as heroic) and even employing the police to conduct wake-up raids. Along the way, the story is defined by these injustices, as well as a pitch-black irony for the law-enforcement side in one scene where an arrest is made—only for the officers to realize they have no way to transport a person in a wheelchair or a facility that could accommodate them. It’s harrowing stuff, brought to life with filmmaking choices and an ensemble of performances that are more than convincing.
Yes, Being Heumann has the right idea, and because of its commitment to the harsh reality of this story—rather than to some hindsight-driven schmaltz that might undermine the harshness—those decisions outweigh some of the clunkier aspects, such as a good deal of this relies on some montage editing. Heder has a good story to tell, a worthy subject as the face of that story, and a firm grip on how to tell it.
Rating: *** (out of ****)

Leave a Reply